Fellowes Logo
The Science of Eureka Moments: Why Our Best Ideas Come When We're Not Trying The Science of Eureka Moments: Why Our Best Ideas Come When We're Not Trying

The Science of Eureka Moments: Why Our Best Ideas Come When We're Not Trying

The Original Eureka Story

Picture this: Ancient Greece, around 250 BC. Archimedes, one of history's greatest mathematicians, steps into his bath after a long day of unsuccessfully trying to solve a royal puzzle. As the water rises and spills over the edge, something clicks. He wasn't actively thinking about the problem, yet in this mundane moment, he discovered the principle of displacement — leading to his famous naked run through Syracuse shouting ‘Eureka!’ (I have found it!)

Why Do These Moments Happen in Downtime?

The Pattern of Problem Solving
Psychological research shows that creative problem solving often follows a pattern:

1

Initial focus and struggle with the problem

2

Period of disengagement (inaction on the problem)

3

Sudden insight or solution

The WorkLife Coach

Inaction Means Action in The Brain’s Default Mode Network

When we're not focused on a specific task, our brain switches to what neuroscientists call the Default Mode Network (DMN). Think of it as your brain's backstage crew, working behind the scenes when the main performance (focused thinking) takes a break.

The WorkLife Coach

During these moments:

  • Different brain regions start communicating more freely
  • Past experiences and new information begin to connect in novel ways
  • The pressure of active problem solving lifts, allowing creative associations to form

This explains why solutions often appear during ‘downtime’ like showering, walking the dog or just before falling asleep. We can't force ourselves into this brain switch through concentration — paradoxically, we need to relax to access it.

Famous Examples of Ideas During Downtime

  • J.K. Rowling conceived Harry Potter during a delayed train journey
  • Paul McCartney composed ‘Yesterday’ in a dream
  • Friedrich August Kekulé discovered the ring structure of benzene while dozing by his fireplace — a vision of a snake biting its own tail sparked his breakthrough

How to Create Conditions for Insightful Ideas

1. Prime Your Mind

  • Thoroughly understand the problem
  • Gather relevant information
  • Allow yourself to struggle initially

2. Plan For Downtime

  • Schedule regular breaks
  • Engage in low-attention activities
  • Create space for mind wandering

3. Capture Ideas

  • Keep notes handy
  • Record voice memos
  • Accept that insights might come at inconvenient times

The Modern Challenge

In our always-on, constantly connected world, we rarely give our minds true downtime. We fill every moment with scrolling, checking emails or consuming content. This might be why genuine ‘Eureka moments’ feel increasingly rare. So make space for insight by building it into your routine.

Remember: Sometimes, the best way to solve a problem is to stop trying to solve it!

Sources and Further Reading:

  • A Technique for Producing Ideas, James Webb Young
  • The Eureka Factor, John Kunios and Mark Beeman
  • The Art of Thinking Clearly, Rolf Dobelli
Fellowes WorkLife Coach

WANT TO LIVE YOUR BEST WORKLIFE?

From headspace to workspace I will help you make the best decisions for you and your people. Together we will explore tips and advice for creating a better WorkLife.

DISCOVER MY CONTENT HUB
Bibi